Measurement · · 4 min read

Could Bill Gates daughter face prison time for cookie stuffing?

Phoebe Gates, daughter of Bill and Melinda Gates, is in the press lately for an alleged "Cookie stuffing" operation. If charged and convicted, penalties could include actual jail time. Do you know how it works?

Could Bill Gates daughter face prison time for cookie stuffing?
(Disclosure: Generative AI assisted in the creation of this image.)

How Cookie Stuffing Actually Works

You may have seen the headlines by now. Bill Gates' daughter. A buzzy shopping startup called Phia. Celebrity investors. And a Bloomberg investigation alleging the whole thing was juiced by ad fraud.

More specifically, a tactic as old as digital marketing called "cookie stuffing."

Just a quick fact check before continuing. No charges have been filed. Phia and its founders face allegations, an affiliate network suspension, and some very unflattering Slack logs. Legal experts noted that cookie stuffing is typically prosecuted as federal wire fraud, which technically carries a maximum of 20 years. <-- That is where the scary number comes from.

But let us just pause for a moment and take in the fact that 7 years before Phoebe Gates was born, Microsoft deployed the cookie spec into Internet Explorer. Her father founded and lead the company while her mother was also a senior member of management at the time. Even though cookies were invented by the team at Netscape, IE was the browser that drove explosive growth.

Then, 31 years later, the market alleges that their daughter's tech startup was involved in a large-scale media attribution scandal. This is the type of drama nerds dream of.

The honest handshake that never was

So what is the actual alleged crime? It is one of the oldest hacks in ad tech

Affiliate marketing operates on a pretty simple agreement that if you drive sales, you get paid a commission. The ways we prove who drove what sale is the tricky bit.

In overly simplified terms:

  1. A publisher writes about a product.
  2. You click their link.
  3. Your browser stores a tracking cookie.
  4. You buy the product.
  5. The merchant sees the cookie and pays the publisher a commission.

The entire system rests on one assumption: the cookie "proves" influence.

Cookie stuffing breaks that assumption. Someone plants an affiliate cookie in your browser without you ever clicking anything. You later buy something on your own. Direct visit, Google search, whatever. The merchant's billing attribution vendor looks up the planted cookie and pays a commission to someone who did nothing.

It is attribution theft. I call it last-click larceny.

The plumbing

Your browser is trusting by design. When a page tells it to fetch a resource, it fetches. If the responding server sends back a cookie, the browser stores it. Few questions asked.

Fraudsters exploit that trust a few ways:

Invisible iframes. A 1x1 pixel frame loads an entire affiliate landing page behind the scenes. You never see it. The cookie drops anyway.

Fake images. An image tag points to an affiliate link instead of an actual image. To render a piece of content for you to enjoy, the browser requests the "image" for an article you are reading. Instead, it receives a tracking cookie and silently fails to render anything.

Browser extensions. This is the modern version, and the one that matters here. If you didn't know, browser extensions run with "elevated permissions" across every site you visit. Remember how you just blindly clicked "accept" when you installed that plugin? You opened the door. An extension can watch your tabs, detect when you reach a checkout page, and fire a hidden background request that injects its own affiliate cookie seconds before you hit "buy."

That last one should sound familiar since Phia operates as a popular browser extension.

What Phia allegedly did

Phia is a browser extension that finds discount codes and price comparisons while you shop. Useful premise with real users.

But independent audits found the extension doing something extra. In one test, a user clicked a Nordstrom link inside a Wirecutter article. During checkout, Phia opened a background tab, loaded its own referral link, and overwrote Wirecutter's attribution tag.

As we reviewed earlier, Wirecutter did the work. It generated a legitimate click to purchase. However, Phia allegedly took the credit and commission.

The company blamed a bug it discovered "within the last 24 hours." But then Bloomberg surfaced internal messages that suggested the founders knew about the cookie-dropping features.

For how long? At least seven months.

The revenue math is...woof. The alleged stuffing accounted for roughly 51% of the merchandise value Phia earned in June.

Half the revenue was a bug? A woopsie?

After the features were disabled in July, daily revenue reportedly dropped from $80,000 to somewhere between $10,000 and $28,000.

We've been down this road before

The legal precedent here is almost as old as the digital ad market itself. In the mid-2000s, eBay's two highest-paid affiliates ran a cookie stuffing operation that hoovered in over $33 million combined. Shawn Hogan and Brian Dunning both pled guilty to federal wire fraud and went to prison.

From that point forward, sending deceptive tracking signals across state lines to manipulate an attribution engine became clearly established wire fraud. Full stop. Furthermore, anomalies and "coding glitches" counted as active concealment.

And the browser extension version? Also not new.

Honey, the PayPal-owned coupon extension is fighting more than two dozen class actions over nearly identical allegations.

Why you should care

If you buy media or run affiliate programs, this fraud is invisible reports.

Actually, it is worse than invisible. It shows up as your best-performing channel. The stuffer steals credit at the last second, your organic and paid channels look weak, and you shift budget toward the alleged thief.

The fix is architectural:

The truth is that last-click attribution built this mess. Clients are addicted because it makes them look like marketing heros. Agencies love it because it is not a difficult KPI to achieve.

As long as one cookie decides who gets paid, someone will find a way to plant that cookie. Audit your affiliate mix this quarter. If a partner's conversions all happen within seconds of their clicks, you found a stuffer.

Read next

Public media dies in 6 weeks
News ·

Public media dies in 6 weeks

Every one of us in commercial media has benefited from PBS and NPR. If we let them die on our watch, we're complicit in destroying the best of what American media can be.