> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.adlingo.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# POV: Retail Media Guidelines
- URL: https://www.adlingo.org/pov-retail-media-guidelines/
- Published: 2024-02-22T10:00:56.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-28T14:20:57.000Z
- Description: The surface scratched, depths untouched. I mixed take on the newly proposed Retail Media guidelines.
- Author: Travis Lusk
- Tags: Retail Media

When a brand is "encouraged" (read: required) to purchase paid ads from their retail distribution partners, is it any wonder that the multi-billion dollar category lacks standards? Well, here we are.

The [IAB/MRC Retail Media Measurement Guidelines](https://www.iab.com/insights/retail-media-measurement-guidelines/?ref=adlingo.org) represent a significant step forward in the attempt to bring order and consistency to retail media. The explosive growth in this category is eyewatering, as too is the lack of standardization.

I encourage you to read the first few summary pages at least to get a sense of where the industry is.

[Download: IAB/MRC Guidelines](https://www.iab.com/insights/retail-media-measurement-guidelines/?ref=adlingo.org)

Yet, while they provide a foundation for measurement standards, they are a starter home in a neighborhood that's destined for skyscrapers. Our industry needs to be better and faster at adopting standards as new channels and technologies emerge.

Does retail media even matter? **Yes**.

A recent article by *Marketing Dive* (see below), quoted [Ryan Mayward](https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryan-mayward-b67458/?ref=adlingo.org), SVP of Retail Media at Walmart Connect:

> “It’s a channel with broadcast-level scale.” 

[‘Broadcast-level scale’: Why retail media networks view in-store as their next frontierThe in-store experience was positioned as a broadcast TV-sized opportunity at NRF’s Big Show, but not everyone seemed convinced.![](https://www.marketingdive.com/apple-touch-icon.png?v=2)Marketing DivePeter Adams![](https://www.marketingdive.com/imgproxy/rwjUr0QOluVKUd-46QyboFcgh4Qi24sKMJfZgTmf5fs/g:ce/rs:fill:770:435:0/bG9jYWw6Ly8vZGl2ZWltYWdlL0dldHR5SW1hZ2VzLTEwNDExNDc1NjAuanBn.webp)](https://www.marketingdive.com/news/retail-media-networks-in-store-advertising-NRF-big-show/704675/?ref=adlingo.org)

Let's dissect why these guidelines are a necessary baseline but still fall short of the comprehensive blueprint needed for the retail media sector's maturity and growth.

## TL;DR

### Pros

1. **Standardization**: The guidelines provide a standardized framework for retail media, which can help streamline processes and create consistency across the industry.
2. **Transparency**: They aim to increase transparency in the retail media ecosystem, which can benefit both advertisers and retailers by providing clearer guidelines for collaboration and data usage. (I wish this were more of a requirement and less of a suggestion.)
3. **Improved Consumer Protection**: The guidelines may contribute to a more coherent consumer protection framework for online advertising issues, addressing potential issues associated with targeting, such as discrimination and inappropriate targeting.

### Cons

1. **Resource Intensive**: Adhering to the guidelines may require significant resources and effort to ensure compliance, especially for smaller retailers and advertisers.
2. **Lack of Regulatory Oversight**: There are concerns about limited regulatory oversight of online platforms in terms of alignment of policies and guidelines with industry practices, which could impact the efficacy of the guidelines.

## **A Foray into Ambition: The Good**

The guidelines offer a semblance of structure, addressing crucial areas like ad viewability, audience measurement, and invalid garbage traffic.

They are a testament to the mainstream digital industry's recognition of the need for standardized practices that ensure transparency and accountability. In a sector where ambiguity reigns, these guidelines serve as a starting point.

Swift development and adoption of industry standards is not just a necessity but a strategic imperative. Historically, the advertising sector has prided itself on some semblance of established benchmarks that foster fairness, enhance transparency, and promote efficiency across the board. (Perhaps that is more aspirational than reality!) 

Our market is a testament to innovation, yet it demands a framework that can adapt as quickly as the technologies and methodologies it employs. 

Advertisers, publishers, and consumers alike stand to benefit from this rapid evolution of standards, as it promises a future where innovation, fairness, and transparency are not just ideals but operational realities.

## **Where's the beef?**

However, the guidelines are like a diet that's all greens with no protein; they're healthy but hardly satisfying. They touch on the surface of issues without delving deep into the commercially self-serving incentives where retail media problems lie.

Classic Wendy's "Where's the beef?" spot from the 1980's.

For instance, the complexities of cross-platform measurement, the nuances of consumer privacy in a surveillance-oriented marketplace, and the intricacies of integrating offline and online data are treated with kid gloves.

These areas require not just guidelines but requirements that boldly address the sector's existential challenges. Hopefully, that’s coming next.

A closer examination of the document reveals that these initial standards, while foundational, barely graze the complexities we inherently need.

This critique, aimed at industry professionals like you and me, digs into the nuances that the guidelines overlook, highlighting the critical areas that demand deeper consideration for the standards to be truly comprehensive.

If you are more of a "learn by listening" kind of person, here's a great episode of Marketecture about retail media.

## **The Surface Scratched, Depths Untouched**

Firstly, the guidelines provide a framework that, on the surface, appears to address the myriad challenges in retail media. 

However, a critical eye reveals a significant oversight in addressing cross-platform measurement. 

In a time where consumers seamlessly transition across devices and platforms, the guidelines offer little direction on harmonizing measurement across these varied touchpoints, leaving a gaping hole in the quest for a unified measurement model.

We must also keep in mind that retail media is a net-new cost for many advertisers.

"Through one lens, Retail Media is [another toll both for brands to navigate](https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/why-unilever-pg-coke-ramping-ad-investment-slow-market-billy-ryan-q3xve%3FtrackingId=xnt%252BpWAOS%252BG4z4Qx%252FhD2Zg%253D%253D/?trackingId=xnt%2BpWAOS%2BG4z4Qx%2FhD2Zg%3D%3D&ref=adlingo.org)," wrote [Billy Ryan](https://www.linkedin.com/in/billy-ryan-78850343/?ref=adlingo.org) of the7Stars.

### **Privacy: Punted to the Other Team**

The guidelines tiptoe around the colossal issue of consumer privacy. 

In today's market, where data privacy and security have taken center stage, the document's treatment of privacy concerns appears cursory at best. The need for a robust, transparent framework that prioritizes consumer privacy while balancing the advertisers' objectives is more pressing than ever. 

Just look at Walmart's [land grab acquisition of tv set manufacturer Vizo](https://www.theverge.com/2024/2/20/24078060/walmart-vizio-acquisition-deal?ref=adlingo.org) announced yesterday. Walmart is buying a data company that happens to make TV's.

> "With growing privacy concerns and the eventual phasing out of third-party cookies, first-party data (collected directly from customers) is the new gold," wrote Priya Bajaj. "Walmart already has massive customer data from its stores and website; [Vizio adds an entirely new dimension](https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/walmarts-acquisition-vizio-seismic-shift-retail-adtech-priya-bajaj-rxv9e%3FtrackingId=vEscmbLbS6OppQC1Qaqumg%253D%253D/?trackingId=bl99uHoWRxuvbi9PlQRsbw%3D%3D&ref=adlingo.org) to that treasure trove." - [Priya Bajaj](https://www.linkedin.com/in/priyabajaj12/?ref=adlingo.org) from Google.

[Walmart to acquire Vizio in $2.3 billion dealWalmart will own smart TVs for its retail stores.![](https://www.theverge.com/icons/apple_touch_icon.png)The Verge![](https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/q7qj6x4cfzBcCCue295cdtkjkdc=/0x0:2040x1360/1200x628/filters:focal(1020x680:1021x681)/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25295334/STK257_VISIO__B.jpg)](https://www.theverge.com/2024/2/20/24078060/walmart-vizio-acquisition-deal?ref=adlingo.org)

This thinness of the current spec not only undermines the guidelines' effectiveness but also highlights a missed opportunity to lead the industry towards a more ethical, consumer-centric approach.

At this point, I can only assume that the intent is for the RMN sector to adopt the same standards as the digital mainstream. 

However, the entire category exists because of retailers' first-party relationships with known customers. If anything, retailers and their clients could set the standards for the rest of the mainstream digital ecosystem.

### **The Illusion of Compliance**

Compliance is presented as a checkbox exercise, a formality rather than a culture. The reality is far more complicated.

In an industry that evolves quickly, yesterday's best practices become today's archaic relics.

Compliance should not be about adhering to the letter of the guidelines but embodying their spirit, evolving as the landscape shifts beneath our feet.

Plus, we need to move away from self-attestation of compliance and adopt a culture of robust auditing by independent third parties.

## **The Future**

The retail media sector's potential is undeniable, but its foundation is shaky. The guidelines are a step in the right direction, but we must move faster, ideally, with some real teeth.

The market is a behemoth growing by over $100B in the next few years. It is taking off in the US, but also gaining traction around the world. Amazon, Alibaba, and Walmart [are the dominant incumbents](https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/sleeping-giant-awakens-why-retail-media-poised-dominate-yash-shah-dadwc%3FtrackingId=Fi1yk3aqRuSuHsuGPadGDA%253D%253D/?trackingId=Fi1yk3aqRuSuHsuGPadGDA%3D%3D&ref=adlingo.org) according to [Yash Shah](https://www.linkedin.com/in/yashshah1211/?ref=adlingo.org) at Media.Monks.

We need to grow up, and fast. We need comprehensive strategies that address not just the "how" of measurement but the "why," ensuring that retail media growth is sustainable, ethical, and consumer-centric. Today, it is **none** of those three things.

The guidelines are better than nothing, I suppose. I applaud the effort it took to even get this far.

However, they are far from the comprehensive roadmap needed for the retail media sector to mature into the giant it will inevitably be.

Our community of professionals must rise to the challenge, crafting a future that respects consumer privacy, embraces transparency, and fosters innovation. This will not happen organically. It needs to be driven (demanded) by marketers.

We have a little bit of momentum now. Let's not squander it.